In a case with “horrific” facts, a federal appeals court has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit against Omegle, a video chat platform, filed by the parents of a New Jersey child who was sexually exploited by a stranger she met online.
The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals acknowledged the tragic nature of the case, where an 11-year-old girl was coerced into performing sexual acts on camera by a predator who threatened her and her family.
However, the court ruled that Omegle is protected from liability under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which shields online platforms from responsibility for content generated by users.
READ: Florida Social Media Law Faces Court Challenge In 2026
The parents argued that Omegle should be held accountable because the platform allegedly knew that predators used its services to target children. They pointed to Omegle’s features like anonymity, lack of age verification, and insufficient data protection as contributing factors.
However, the court determined that the parents failed to demonstrate that Omegle had “actual knowledge” of the specific instance of sex trafficking involving their daughter, a requirement for an exception to Section 230 immunity. The judges emphasized that while Omegle might have been aware of the potential for abuse on its platform, it did not have direct knowledge of this particular incident.
READ: Virginia Sheriff Details Deadly Consequences Of Border Crisis In Exclusive Testimony
The court also rejected the parents’ claims under “Masha’s Law,” which allows victims to sue individuals who possess child pornography. The judges stated that the lawsuit did not plausibly allege that Omegle possessed or had knowledge of the explicit images created during the exploitation of the child.
Judge Barbara Lagoa dissented on the Masha’s Law aspect, arguing that the parents had presented a plausible claim. She highlighted the allegations that Omegle knew minors used its platform and that child sexual abuse material was pervasive on the site.
Omegle, Once a Hub for Random Connections, Shuts Down After Years of Child Exploitation Concerns
Florida-based Omegle, the popular online chat platform that randomly connected strangers for video conversations, closed its virtual doors in November 2023 after 14 years. The website, plagued by reports of child sexual abuse and exploitation, is finally shutting down, leaving a controversial legacy in its wake.
Founder Leif K-Brooks, in a statement announcing the closure, acknowledged the platform’s original intent to foster global connections and “build on the things I loved about the Internet.” However, he admitted that Omegle had become a haven for malicious activities, including “unspeakably heinous crimes.”
READ: California Man Indicted In Florida For Cyberstalking
Over the years, Omegle faced intense scrutiny and numerous lawsuits for its role in facilitating child pornography and sexual abuse. Just last week, the platform settled a lawsuit involving an 11-year-old user who was paired with a sexual predator.
Brooks expressed the emotional and financial toll of operating Omegle, stating that it was “no longer sustainable.” He thanked users who used the platform for positive purposes but apologized for his inability to continue fighting for a safer environment.
Omegle, launched in 2009, boasted millions of daily users at its peak. Its video recordings often went viral on platforms like YouTube and TikTok, contributing to its widespread popularity.
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Connect with us: Follow the Tampa Free Press on Facebook and Twitter for breaking news and updates.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox.