Court Rejects Claims of Coercion and Suppressed Evidence in Decades-Old Case
The Florida Supreme Court today affirmed the denial of Michael Bernard Bell’s successive motion for postconviction relief and denied his request for a stay of execution, scheduled for July 15, 2025. Bell, who is under two sentences of death for the 1993 murders of Jimmy West and Tamecka Smith, had sought to overturn his conviction based on claims of newly discovered evidence, including alleged prosecutorial misconduct and false testimony.
The opinion stated that Bell failed to establish that the alleged newly discovered evidence would “probably produce an acquittal on retrial” or “yield a less severe sentence.” Chief Justice Carlos Muñiz and Justices Charles Canady, John Couriel, Jamie Grosshans, Meredith Sasso, and Renatha Francis concurred in the decision. Justice Jorge Labarga concurred in the result, again raising concerns about the “extremely short time frame for this case and other recent death warrant cases.”
READ: Armwood High School Teacher Arrested For Showing Obscene Content to Students
Michael Bernard Bell was convicted of the first-degree murders of Jimmy West and Tamecka Smith, which occurred on December 9, 1993. The motive, as established at trial, stemmed from Bell’s desire for revenge against Theodore Wright, who had killed Bell’s brother, Lamar Bell, in a justifiable self-defense shooting in June 1993.
According to trial testimony, Michael Bell acquired an AK-47 assault rifle and, upon seeing Theodore Wright’s car (which Wright had unknowingly sold to his half-brother, Jimmy West), waited for West to leave a liquor lounge with Tamecka Smith and another female. Bell then approached the car, firing twelve bullets into West and four into Smith at point-blank range. He subsequently fired bullets into the front of the lounge and a nearby house where children resided. Bell later confessed to his aunt, “Theodore got my brother and now I got his brother.”
Bell was sentenced to death in 1995. The trial court found three aggravating factors: Bell’s prior violent felony conviction (armed robbery in 1990), the murders being committed in a cold, calculated, and premeditated manner (CCP), and Bell knowingly creating a great risk of death to many persons.
Bell’s convictions and sentences became final in 1998 after the U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari review. Since then, Bell has filed multiple motions for postconviction relief in both state and federal courts, all of which have been denied. His claims have ranged from ineffective assistance of counsel to challenges against the application of legal precedents.
Governor Ron DeSantis signed Bell’s death warrant on June 13, 2025, setting an execution date of July 15, 2025. Following this, Bell filed a successive motion for postconviction relief, alleging newly discovered evidence in the form of Brady and Giglio violations. These claims centered on allegations that Detective William Bolena (now deceased) and Assistant State Attorney George Bateh engaged in a pattern of misconduct, coercing witnesses and suppressing exculpatory evidence.
READ: Driver Critically Injured In Violent New Port Richey Crash
Bell presented five witnesses at an evidentiary hearing on June 23, 2025: Henry Edwards, Charles Jones, Ericka Williams, Vanness “Ned” Pryor, and Paula Goins. Bell claimed that Edwards and Jones had recanted their trial testimony, and that Williams, Pryor, and Goins provided new information about alleged police and prosecutorial coercion.
The Supreme Court, agreeing with the circuit court, found Bell’s claims regarding newly discovered evidence to be without merit and, in most cases, untimely.
Henry Edwards and Charles Jones: The Court highlighted the unreliability of recanted testimony. While Edwards and Jones had signed affidavits purporting to recant their trial statements, both either denied the contents of their affidavits under oath at the evidentiary hearing or largely invoked their Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination. The Court stated that Edwards’s “failure to recant his previous testimony under oath at the evidentiary hearing is ultimately fatal to Defendant’s claim.” Similarly, Jones’s refusal to answer questions left “the Court nothing to evaluate the credibility of.” The Court also found these claims untimely, noting Bell’s failure to prove when the alleged recantations were or could have been discovered with due diligence.
READ: Florida Death Row Inmate Loran K. Cole Executed After 30 Years: Final Moments Witnessed By 19
Ericka Williams, Vanness “Ned” Pryor, and Paula Goins: Bell alleged that these witnesses were coerced or threatened into providing false testimony. However, the Court found no evidence to support these claims, concluding that the witnesses’ descriptions of interactions with law enforcement and prosecutors did not constitute “undue pressure.” For instance, Goins’s testimony about being told she could lose her job or custody of her granddaughter if she didn’t tell the truth was deemed to be a general outlining of “reasonable possible outcomes” rather than coercion. The Court also found these claims to be untimely, noting that Bell had raised similar coercion claims in previous postconviction proceedings.
The Supreme Court concluded that Bell failed to demonstrate any Brady violation (failure to disclose favorable evidence) or Giglio violation (knowing presentation of false testimony) that would undermine confidence in the outcome of his trial. Given the “overwhelming evidence of Bell’s guilt and evidence in support of the aggravating factors,” the Court found that the alleged newly discovered evidence would not likely lead to an acquittal or a less severe sentence.
Consequently, the Court affirmed the denial of Bell’s successive motion for postconviction relief and denied his motion for a stay of execution and request for oral argument. The mandate is set to issue immediately, bringing Michael Bernard Bell closer to his execution date of July 15, 2025.
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Connect with us: Follow the Tampa Free Press on Facebook and Twitter for breaking news and updates.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox.
