HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, Fla. – A months-long internal investigation into academic cheating has led to the departure of six high-ranking officials from the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office (HCSO), profoundly shaking the department’s command structure and raising serious concerns about public trust.
The State of the Scandal
The investigation, launched in July, centered on the discovery that six members of the sheriff’s command staff had allegedly sought and received assistance—specifically having a man named Robert Roush complete academic assignments—for them. The assignments were for various policing courses, including the elite FBI National Academy coursework.
The fallout has been swift and decisive:
- Four officials resigned while under investigation: Chief Deputy Anthony Collins, Colonels Michael Hannaford and Chris Rule, and Captain Lora Rivera.
- Two more captains, Zuleydis Stearns and Marvin Johnson, were fired by Sheriff Chad Chronister following the conclusion of the internal probe.
Vacancies left by the upheaval have prompted a series of promotions and lateral moves across the colonels, majors, and captains ranks to restore the agency’s leadership.
A Breach of Trust and High Standards
Sheriff Chad Chronister addressed the public on Monday, emphasizing the gravity of the misconduct.
“The public’s trust depends on the confidence that we are honest, transparent and willing to hold ourselves accountable when we fall short,” Chronister stated. “These actions represent a lapse in judgment and a breach of the higher professional and ethical standards that law enforcement must hold ourselves to.”
While commending the former deputies’ years of service and acknowledging they “are not bad people,” the Sheriff described the incident as “a shortcut, a moment of poor judgment, a choice that, while wrong, was not malicious.”
The Collins Controversy
The investigation was ignited in July by an email from the wife of then-Chief Deputy Anthony Collins, alleging Roush had assisted him with his FBI National Academy coursework.
Collins, who resigned later that month, had only been promoted four months prior, marking him as the highest-ranking Black deputy in the agency’s history and a widely perceived potential successor to Chronister. The revelations have “devastated” Black residents who had high hopes for his continued ascent, according to NAACP Hillsborough chapter president Yvette Lewis.
Collins, along with Roush, has publicly disputed the cheating allegations, telling the Tampa Bay Times in August that he paid Roush only for tutoring and editing and denied that Roush completed the work. However, Sheriff Chronister asserted on Monday that Collins had personally admitted to him that Roush had written half of his FBI National Academy papers for him.
The Sheriff’s Office, which is not currently “aware of” any other members who used Roush, expanded its initial inquiry into Collins to uncover the broader use of Roush by agency leaders for work-related projects and coursework, culminating in the resignations and firings announced this week.
READ: Honoring Heroes: 61st Annual Hillsborough Veterans Day Tribute Set For November 11th
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox.
