In a revealing interview on FOX News Media’s Hang Out with Sean Hannity podcast, legal analyst and former prosecutor Nancy Grace detailed the emotional toll of the ongoing Nancy Guthrie investigation, while drawing stark parallels to the violent tragedy that reshaped her own life decades ago.
Grace addressed the public scrutiny surrounding Savannah Guthrie and her family members, Annie and Cameron, following the disappearance of their mother. She dismissed critics who have questioned the family’s timing and decisions regarding ransom demands.
“There’s no script for what you’re supposed to do,” Grace said, noting that the family had been inundated with “many, many quite fake ransoms.” She clarified that Savannah only responded to two notes she believed were legitimate, likely those funneled through TMZ’s Harvey Levin.
Reflecting on the logistics of the case, Grace noted a troubling detail: the lack of an immediate ransom request. “You take somebody—you want to feed them for a week and then ask for the money? No,” Grace said. She expressed her belief that the family did not pay because they never received “proof of life.”
RELATED: Savannah Guthrie Vows ‘I Believe’ As Search For Mother Continues In Arizona
The case has struck a deep chord with Grace, who described the victim as a frail woman who “could hardly walk to the mailbox.”
Her voice hardened when discussing the perpetrators, stating she wants them to face the death penalty. “By God, if she’s not [alive], the hounds of hell will chase those kidnappers until they are caught,” she vowed.
The conversation took a somber turn as Grace recounted the 1979 murder of her fiancé, Keith, which occurred just before they were set to elope. She described the moment she learned of his death in a “dark phone booth” as a “horrible blur” that resulted in a permanent loss of memory regarding the months surrounding the event.
Following the tragedy, Grace’s weight dropped to 89 pounds, and she dropped out of school, feeling a level of grief so profound she “felt like going out in the dark, in the woods, and just howling like an animal.”
Keith was shot five times—in the face, neck, head, and back—by a disgruntled former construction worker. Grace revealed she has never visited the crime scene or read the trial transcripts, explaining that the trauma still triggers a depression she works hard to keep away from her children.
For years following the murder, Grace admitted she was indifferent to her own safety, often walking through dangerous areas at 1 a.m. unarmed to find witnesses. “I didn’t care if I lived or died,” she told Hannity. “In fact, there were times I thought it would be a relief if I could go be with Keith.”
That mindset eventually shifted after she married her husband, David, in 2007 and had her twins. Today, she says her outlook is the “complete opposite,” driven by a fierce desire to protect her family.
This lifelong mission for justice, she explained, was born directly from the “senseless” violence that took her fiancé and set her on the path to becoming a prosecutor and victim’s advocate.
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox
