In a major ruling on federal sentencing power, the Supreme Court on Wednesday unanimously rejected a long-standing practice used by some courts to automatically extend the supervision of defendants who go on the run.
The case, Rico v. United States, centered on Isabel Rico, a woman who spent years as a fugitive while supposedly under federal oversight.
The justices were asked to decide a simple but high-stakes question: Does the clock stop on a person’s “supervised release” term the moment they stop reporting to their probation officer?
Writing for the Court, Justice Neil Gorsuch delivered a firm “no.”
The “Tolling” Trap
For years, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals — which covers much of the Western U.S. — followed a rule that “tolled,” or paused, the clock for anyone who absconded. Under that logic, if you had a year of supervision left but disappeared for five years, you still owed the government that year the moment you were caught.
The government argued this was only fair. They claimed a defendant shouldn’t get “credit” for time served on supervised release if they weren’t actually being supervised.
But the Supreme Court wasn’t buying it. Justice Gorsuch noted that while the law allows the clock to pause for certain things—like being back in a jail cell for more than 30 days—it says nothing about pausing the clock just because someone is hard to find.
READ: Victor Davis Hanson Says Special Counsel Jack Smith’s Past Is Catching Up
“Automatically extending a term of supervised release is not among the many tools the Sentencing Reform Act provides courts,” Gorsuch wrote. He added that the Ninth Circuit’s rule was less an interpretation of the law and more of an “adornment” to what Congress actually wrote.
A Timeline of Trouble
The legal battle began with Isabel Rico’s complex history with the justice system. After a 2010 drug trafficking conviction, Rico was placed on supervised release. She violated those terms, served a brief stint back in prison, and was handed a new supervision term set to expire in June 2021.
However, Rico went missing in 2017. She wasn’t caught until January 2023. While she was on the run—specifically in early 2022—she committed a new state drug offense.
When she finally appeared back in federal court, the judge treated that 2022 crime as a fresh violation of her federal supervision. Rico argued that was impossible; her federal term had legally ended in 2021, regardless of whether she was a fugitive. The Supreme Court agreed, ruling that because her term had officially expired, the court couldn’t punish her for a new crime committed after that date.
The Lone Dissent
While the decision to strike down the “automatic extension” rule was unanimous, Justice Samuel Alito filed a solo dissent regarding the outcome for Rico herself.
Alito argued the case was “much simpler” than his colleagues made it. He suggested that even if the 2022 crime wasn’t a formal violation, the judge still had the right to look at her behavior while she was a fugitive to decide how long she should stay in prison for her earlier violations.
“I am bemused by the notion that petitioner was on supervised release when she was evading all supervision,” Alito wrote, calling the situation “unsupervised supervised release.”
What This Means for the Future
The ruling is a clear message to Congress: if the government wants the power to freeze the clock on fugitives, the law needs to be rewritten.
As it stands, Justice Gorsuch noted that the government already has tools to handle people who vanish, including issuing arrest warrants that keep a case alive even after a term expires. The Court refused to “rewrite the directions Congress has provided” just to make things easier for prosecutors.
For now, the case heads back to the lower courts to determine a new sentence for Rico, one that doesn’t rely on the 2022 drug charge.
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox
