The Biden administration on Tuesday defended its push to deport fewer illegal immigrants before the Supreme Court.
Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas announced in September 2021 new priorities for deportations that limited illegal migrant apprehensions and removals to risks to national security, public safety and border security.
During Tuesday’s arguments before the high court, the Biden administration argued that states lack the right to sue the federal government like they did in this case.
“This court should reverse. First, the states lack standing. They argue states can challenge any federal policy that imposes even $1 of indirect harms on their own taxing or spending. That theory has no limiting principle,” U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar argued on behalf of the Biden administration.
In the news: Georgia Teen Who Brutally Killed Grandfather In Florida, Now Charged With Raping The Man As He Died
“It’s incompatible with our constitutional structure and it contradicts more than 200 years of history and tradition, where states could not sue the United States on this basis. Federal courts should not now be transformed into open forums for each and every policy dispute between the states and the national government,” Prelogar said.
The state of Texas argued that states should be able to take legal action against the federal government in such cases. It also argued that there are costs that burden the states associated with the federal government’s decision.
“As this court has recognized before, the states bear many of the consequences of federal immigration decisions,” Texas Solicitor General Judd Stone argued on behalf of Texas.
“The law the Biden Administration is trying to ignore is crystal clear: certain illegal aliens that have committed crimes must be detained and cannot be allowed to roam freely in our communities,” Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton said in a statement shared with the Daily Caller News Foundation.